CHINATRUTH

Open Letter from Gao Pu, Son of Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu, and All Relatives and Friends, to Procurator-General Ying Yong of the Supreme People's Procuratorate and President Zhang Jun of the Supreme People's Court

By Weiquan Information CenterPublished Nov 11, 2026

Dear Procurator-General Ying Yong of the Supreme People's Procuratorate and President Zhang Jun of the Supreme People's Court:

Today we write to you publicly with grief and indignation to expose the absurd violations of legal procedure and the trampling of substantive justice by the Beilin District People's Procuratorate and Beilin District People's Court of Xi'an City, Shaanxi Province, in the review for prosecution and trial of the case of Gao Quanfu, Pang Yu and Tang Bingyi.

Gao Quanfu, his wife Pang Yu, and Tang Bingyi were the senior pastor, pastor's wife and pastor, respectively, of the Xi'an Zion Light Church. Since the case came to light on 16 May 2025, Xi'an authorities have forcibly framed the tithes and offerings of a Christian house church as money that the three defendants defrauded from believers.

During the investigation, the handling units, through threats, enticement and other means, forced believers to admit that the offerings they gave the church were defrauded property, and artificially split a single joint-crime case into three cases, producing different case-file materials for each. During the review for prosecution, the procuratorate did not interview the 'victims' in accordance with law, accepted the police opinions in full, and brought the case to court as three cases.

Since the case was brought to court on 31 December 2025, the court has delayed opening the trial and has not informed the lawyers of any extension of the time limit for trial. After reviewing the file, the lawyers found that the procuratorate had not prepared the list of victims and their contact details as required, and asked the court to urge the procuratorate to provide them. However, despite repeated requests and urging by the defence, the handling judges have not substantively responded to the defence's requests, and have only verbally replied that the victims identified by the procuratorate are the 235 victims listed in the audit report.

At the meeting with the handling judge on 6 November 2026, defence counsel pointed out that the Pang Yu case file did not contain the record of the interview with victim Zhao Qian, who is listed in the indictment. Gao Quanfu's lawyer pointed out that Gao Quanfu's case file did contain Zhao Qian's record. This once again confirms the fact that the police and procuratorate deliberately split the case materials. Judge Luo Yixian checked the Pang Yu case file held by the court on the spot and found that the court's file indeed did not contain Zhao Qian's record. Judge Luo Yixian promised to give a response on this issue by next Monday (before 9 November). However, as of the afternoon of 11 November, the Beilin District Court had not only failed to reply to the lawyers, but had even set its telephone line to an unreachable state.

At the 6 November meeting, Gao Quanfu's defence lawyers requested that the court provide the list of victims, asked that the trial originally scheduled for 12 November be postponed, and pointed out the many matters requiring a pre-trial meeting that had existed previously.

Zhao Yuying and her relatives, who were identified as victims in this case, immediately and urgently retained agent lawyers upon learning that victims have the right to entrust lawyers to attend the proceedings. The agent lawyers contacted the court on 9 November, informing it that they would go to the court on 11 November to review the file and take part in the proceedings, but the assistant who answered the call only replied that the matter would be reported to the collegial panel.

On 10 November, some of the agents in this case learned that the Beilin District Court had notified the justice bureau where the lawyers are based, requesting that it send personnel to observe the trial in order to supervise the lawyers during the hearing.

On the morning of 11 November, the victims' agent lawyer telephoned the court, and the court assistant said they had to ask the judge whether the documents would be accepted. In the afternoon, the victims' agents went to the court to request that the documents be submitted, the file be reviewed and the trial be postponed. However, after more than ten calls to the court, the court not only did not answer the phone but also deliberately did not keep anyone in the office to receive the agent lawyers. It attempted to push ahead with the trial on the 12th illegally, without the 'victims' and their agent lawyers present.

As close relatives of Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu, we are extremely indignant about this. We cannot imagine that the court and the procuratorate would so disregard the legal procedural provisions on case splitting and the guarantee of victims' rights, deliberately deprive lawyers of their relevant rights, and attempt to forcibly push the case forward.

We therefore earnestly request that the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate urgently intervene, investigate the relevant unlawful acts of the handling units in this case, and seriously deal with the personnel concerned.

Gao Pu, son of Gao Quanfu and Pang Yu, together with all relatives and friends

Published in the United States on the evening of 11 November 2026, Beijing time

Related Reporting