CHINATRUTH

Practising Democracy Within the Constitutional Framework: A Record and Analysis of Feng Zhenghu's 2016 Candidacy for Grassroots People's Congress Deputy

By Weiquan Information CenterPublished Nov 16, 2026

In the second half of 2016, county- and township-level People's Congress elections were rolled out across China in succession. In mid-October, Feng Zhenghu, a well-known Shanghai constitutional scholar and civil rights activist, publicly announced that he would lawfully run for deputy to the 16th People's Congress of Yangpu District, Shanghai. From the “spectator voting” of 2011 to the “proactive, lawful campaigning” of 2016, Feng's political practice is not only a natural extension of his personal “constitutional defence and rights protection” actions, but also provides a highly representative sample for observing the legal boundaries and practical operation of China's grassroots electoral system.

I. Background to the Candidacy: From “Spectator Voting” to “Active Practice”

In the 117th constituency election of Yangpu District in November 2011, Feng Zhenghu, whose personal freedom was under strict control and whose right to seek redress had been deprived, chose not to run as an independent candidate and instead completed voting procedures as an ordinary voter. At the time he wrote “Election Record”, mocking the absence of candidate information and the fact that the election process was a mere formality, while expressing cautious observation of the legal channels for candidacy within the system.

Five years later, in 2016, facing a new round of district People's Congress deputy elections, Feng Zhenghu changed his strategy. Relying on the Constitution of the People's Republic of China and the Election Law of the National People's Congress and Local People's Congresses of the People's Republic of China, he decided to fully activate the legal right to be elected enjoyed by an ordinary Chinese citizen. He completed voter registration at the Zhengmin Residents' Committee of Wujiaochang Subdistrict, Yangpu District, and was formally assigned to Yangpu District Constituency 115.

Feng Zhenghu's candidacy was not blind confrontation, but was grounded in clear legal basis and normative awareness. He expressly cited Article 29 of the Election Law, which provides that “ten or more voters jointly may nominate candidates for deputies”, and launched a public joint nomination request to the voters of the constituency, stressing that candidates nominated by voters have equal legal standing with candidates nominated by political parties and people's organisations.

II. Campaign Platform and Campaign Activities

1. Campaign Slogan and Six Commitments on Livelihood and Civil Rights

Feng Zhenghu put forward the campaign slogan “Defending the Constitution and Protecting Rights, a Happy Life” as its core. Drawing on his long experience of rights protection and the practical demands of grassroots voters, he set out six specific commitments on participation in and deliberation of public affairs:

  • Defending the Constitution and protecting rights: uphold the authority of the Constitution, ensure that national laws and regulations are effectively enforced in Yangpu District, and lawfully protect the legitimate rights and interests of every voter in the constituency;
  • Participating in governance for the people: maintain close contact with grassroots residents, listen to public opinion, speak on their behalf, promote the abolition of bad regulations that infringe on the public's rights, and strengthen the statutory supervision by the People's Congress over the “one government, two yuan” (the government, the courts and the procuratorates);
  • Beautiful homes: promote standardised governance of grassroots communities, lawfully safeguard and support the work of homeowners' committees, and protect the lawful property rights and interests of residents and homeowners;
  • Elderly enjoyment: attend to the realities of an ageing society, and improve material livelihood security, medical care and health, and cultural and recreational participation for elderly residents in the community;
  • Helping the weak: focus on the disadvantaged and on vulnerable groups whose lawful rights have been infringed, and promote channelling petition disputes onto the track of resolution under the rule of law;
  • Happy life: advocate practising the socialist core values of freedom, equality, justice and the rule of law, and pursue a dignified life for every ordinary citizen, free from fear and with a sense of security and peace of mind.

2. Attempts at Modern Campaign Methods

Feng Zhenghu regarded this candidacy as a public process of civic education and popularisation of the law:

Issuing open letters and vote-solicitation letters: he printed the “Joint Letter Recommending Feng Zhenghu as a Candidate for Yangpu District People's Congress Deputy” and the “Vote-Solicitation Letter to Voters”, systematically setting out his personal biography (including a master's degree in economics from Fudan University, scholarly experience in Japan, founding of companies, and advocacy of the “I Want to File a Case” movement), his reasons for running, and his six commitments.

Direct dialogue through public contact details: he fully disclosed his personal mobile number, email address, WeChat ID, home address and landline, proactively accepting consultations, supervision and suggestions from voters, and practising the direct interaction between candidate and voter found in modern representative democracy.

Advocating the lawful remedy of “choosing another person”: when the official preliminary screening and joint nomination process met institutional resistance and his candidacy failed to enter the formal candidate list, Feng Zhenghu did not give up. Relying on the Election Law's provision that “voters may vote in favour, may vote against, may choose any other voter, or may abstain”, he appealed to the voters of Constituency 115 before polling day on 16 November: please handwrite the name “Feng Zhenghu” in the “choose another person” box on the ballot.

III. Practical Obstacles and Institutional Barriers Faced by Feng Zhenghu's Candidacy

Feng Zhenghu's candidacy vividly illustrates the institutional constraints and practical obstacles faced by independent candidates in grassroots elections:

1. Procedural nullification of joint nomination: Although the Constitution and laws grant citizens the right to joint nomination by ten people, in grassroots practice electoral committees often use non-public mechanisms such as “pre-election”, “consultation and deliberation” and “political vetting” to filter out candidates who are not officially designated or are regarded as “sensitive”. As a result, independent joint nominations struggle to become candidates on the formal ballot list.

2. Tension between stability maintenance and electoral rights: During the candidacy period, as a dissident and rights activist under long-term key surveillance, Feng Zhenghu and his supporters faced multiple pressures, including community grid-based stability maintenance, information blockage and restrictions on action, and the space for lawful campaign publicity was highly compressed. For example, five people who volunteered to support Feng Zhenghu's campaign, namely Xu Peiling, Zheng Peipei, Cui Fangfang, Fan Guijuan and Dai Zhongyao, were administratively detained for five days, and on the day before polling day were taken into the Yangpu District Detention Centre in Shanghai.

3. Practical limits of the “choose another person” mechanism: Although the Election Law establishes the “choose another person” system, in an environment lacking free campaign speeches, where voters are mutually unfamiliar and grassroots vote counting and monitoring procedures lack transparency, dispersed “choose another person” votes can hardly reach the statutory absolute majority (more than half of valid votes) required for election.

IV. Historical and Practical Significance of the 2016 Candidacy

Although Feng Zhenghu was not ultimately elected, his practice in the 2016 Yangpu District People's Congress election has several important dimensions of significance:

1. A constitutional experiment upholding the “legalist” path

Feng Zhenghu's candidacy has always been strictly confined within the existing Constitution and laws. He did not adopt drastic confrontation outside the system, but insisted on “having laws to rely on and protecting rights according to law”. This approach not only minimised the political and legal risks of rights activity to the greatest extent, but also directly placed the officially proclaimed rule-of-law discourse (such as governing the country according to law, safeguarding human rights, and whole-process people's democracy) under the test of concrete institutional practice, demonstrating a rational, peaceful and constructive path of civic participation.

2. Activating civic electoral rights and grassroots political awareness

For a long time, China's grassroots People's Congress elections have faced a common dilemma: voter apathy, formalised turnout, and the sense that “it makes no difference who is chosen”. By distributing campaign platforms and vote-solicitation letters, and appealing to voters “not to give up the ballot in your hand, and not to misuse the ballot in your hand”, Feng Zhenghu broke the rigid pattern of “circling names as a mere formality”. He publicised to the public the specific rules of Article 29, Article 31 and the “choose another person” provision of the Election Law, turning cold legal provisions into civic rights that people can understand and feel.

3. Linking macro rule-of-law demands with micro livelihood interests

Unlike activities detached from livelihood issues that only voice political slogans, Feng Zhenghu's campaign commitments closely address residents' real concerns: from homeowners' committee rights protection in old residential estates, to elderly care and public healthcare, to resolving the lawful rights of petitioners. He demonstrated that “defending the Constitution and protecting rights” is not an empty political concept, but a practical tool for safeguarding ordinary residents' housing property, retirement benefits and residential security, providing a down-to-earth model for civil constitutional practice.

4. Promoting enlightenment on the modern concept of the “political contract” at the grassroots

In Feng Zhenghu's conception, People's Congress deputies are not lofty officials or merely decorative model workers, but people's representatives who accept voters' entrustment and work on voters' behalf. In his vote-solicitation letter he proactively disclosed personal information, made concrete and verifiable commitments to perform his duties, and encouraged voters to supervise his words and deeds afterwards. This conduct introduced the concept of a modern political contract at the grassroots, and played a substantive enlightening role in dispelling the subject mentality of “officials selecting officials” among the public.

Conclusion

Feng Zhenghu's candidacy in Yangpu District Constituency 115 in autumn 2016 was a rigorous practice in which civil forces in China explored constitutional democracy within the track of law. It acts like a mirror: it reflects the institutional shortcomings of the grassroots electoral system that urgently need improvement in implementing constitutional rights, and it also shows the resilience and wisdom of Chinese citizens who, within constrained real-world space, take the law as their shield and the ballot as their instrument, persistently expanding the space for public participation.

Author: Feng Zhenghu 16 November 2026


Related Reporting